When building new models for serving dual eligibles, it is essential that those models provide adequate access to providers that are able to serve the unique needs of dual eligibles. In particular, measures of network adequacy need to take into account the high number of dual eligibles who have multiple chronic conditions, including dementia, who are very frail, who have disabilities, and who are limited English proficient. Integrated model networks must include appropriate ratios of primary care providers with training in geriatrics to the population to be enrolled, an adequate specialist network including a sufficient number of specialists in diseases and conditions affecting the dual eligible population and a range of high quality nursing facility and home and community based provider options.
- Illinois proposes that specialists should be permitted to act as Primary Care Providers. (Illinois proposal at 12)
When setting standards for network adequacy, it is important that the standards take into account the number of network providers who actually are accepting new patients, wait times for appointments, cultural competency, physical accessibility, and geographic accessibility. The fact that many members of this population do not drive and may instead rely on public transportation must be taken into account. In urban and suburban areas with public transportation, accessibility criteria should be based on times required when using public transportation and not rely solely on drive times.
- Oregon proposes that managed care plans should undertake an annual community needs assessment at the beginning of the demonstration project and update it annually. The needs assessment would provide information on community health needs, health disparities, resources and barriers to care, and typical patterns of health care utilization. Plans would then use the information to assess whether their provider networks and points of access are sufficient to meet the needs of their local communities. Where capacity is under or over-developed, managed care plans would make plans to strengthen or adjust network capacity as needed beyond the stated minimum standards. Such plans may require workforce development or redesign to address and eliminate disparities over time. (Oregon draft proposal at 19)
- Illinois proposes that plans should be required to analyze network adequacy on a weekly basis in the first three months after implementation, monthly in the next three months and quarterly thereafter. Plans will be required to immediately identify gaps and develop recruiting strategies as necessary. Plans will be required to have contingency plans in case of network inadequacy, a provider contract termination, or insolvency. (Illinois proposal at 12)
- New York advocates propose that, to ensure adequate choice of nursing facilities, the state should require plans to contract with any nursing facility that meets specified standards. Standards could reflect criteria such as placement in the top 60 percent of nursing facilities based on the state’s quality measure performance rankings, or nursing facilities with Medicaid rates within a specified range of the median cost for the region. (NY advocate comments on Incentives at 4)
- Idaho proposes the following appointment standards: Preventive care-42 calendar days; routine assessment-30 days; non urgent medical care-7 days; urgent care-24 hours; wait time in provider’s office- less than 45 minutes; 24 hour coverage and physician access. (Idaho draft proposal at 18)
- New York proposes a somewhat different standard. Waiting times in provider offices cannot exceed one hour. Emergency care must be available immediately. Urgent care must be available within 24 hours of request. Sick visits must be available within 24-72 hours of request. Routine, non-urgent preventive appointments must be available within 4 weeks of request. Non-urgent specialist visits must be available within 2-4 weeks of request.(NY draft at 11)
In addition to having expertise and being available for appointments, network providers must be prepared to provide special accommodations to dual eligibles. For example, the integrated model should enforce policies and payment structures that incorporate longer appointment times than are typically allocated for the general population. For many reasons—complex health conditions, limited English proficiency, disability, mental health condition—many members of this population require longer appointments if their needs are to be fully understood and appropriately addressed.
- Illinois proposes that plans must have1) a toll free number available 24/7 for enrollees to confirm eligibility for benefits and seek prior approval for treatment and that plans must asure a24 hour access by phone to medical professionals, either to the plan directly or o the PCPs tfor consultation to obtain medical care; 2) a toll-free number available, at a minimum during working hours on business days to confirm eligibility for benefits, for approval of non-emergency services, and for enrollees to call to request PCP changes, to file complaints or grievances, to request disenrollment, to ask questions, or to obtain other administrative information; and 3) a toll-free nurse advice line, available 24/7 and that the plan must ensure that the nurses staffing the nurse advice line will be able to obtain physician support and advice. (Illinois proposal at 18)
Finally, integrated models must ensure that they can provide 24/7 access to non-emergency care help lines staffed by medical professionals and to non-emergency room medical services. Rigorous standards for wait times, appointments, and customer service should be set.
Even where integrated models have met these standards for network adequacy, there must still be a process for granting exemptions to receive services from out-of-network providers when those are the only providers capable of providing the needed care. No closed network will be able to meet all of the medical needs of this diverse and often medically fragile population.